James Vick bristling at ‘ridiculous’ lack of promotion by the UFC: ‘This sh-t’s a joke’

For many fighters, getting to the UFC is a dream that carries with it the eventual goals of fame and fortune. Sign that first contract to step into the Octagon, and from there on the proof of their potential will come from their performances. Win and win big and a fighter will become a star on the biggest stage in mixed martial arts.

Actually making that happen, as absurd as it feels to say, is a lot more difficult than just winning fights. That’s a lesson lightweight James Vick has been learning the hard way, during his near half decade with the promotion.

A competitor on season 15 of the Ultimate Fighter, Vick has been something of a divisive figure among fans. Mostly due to his relationship with coach and notorious creep Lloyd Irvin. But that hardly seems like the kind of association that would hold him back with the UFC. Especially in light of his 9-1 record with the promotion; a record dotted with exciting submission and knockout wins.

Nevertheless, while he’s slowly clawed his way into an ‘official’ rankings slot, the now #11 lightweight in the division sounds like he’s still having a lot of trouble getting the recognition he feels he deserves. He vented his frustrations with UFC matchmaking and promoting in a recent interview with Submission Radio.

“OK, just without saying his name, and I know you’re thinking of probably the right person, you know how the other day he posted something about a main event?” Vick said, in response to a social media post from #14 ranked lightweight Paul Felder about a potential fight between the two men.

“If we’re thinking about the same person, I’m not gonna say his name yet, but I was never offered a main event. Let’s be clear about that. I have never been offered a main event. I was told that I’d be on the main card. That’s what I was told, that I’d be on the fuckin’ main card. That’s not a fucking main event and it’s not even a fucking pay-per-view. So once again, this plays right into what you’re saying with my relationship with the UFC. I don’t understand it, I don’t fucking get it.

“And when I was on the phone yesterday negotiating with the Sean Shelby, that was brought up. I said, ‘Why the fuck am I 9-1 in the UFC, I’ve never been on a main card of a pay-per-view?’ I’ve never been on a countdown show? I’ve never… I’ve been flown out to one event. last year I got flown out to international fight week and that’s it. I said, ‘I’ve never been…’ I said, ‘This is fucking ridiculous, man.’ And his answer was, ‘That’s not my department’. Well, maybe you should talk to that department, you know what I’m saying? I don’t understand it either. I mean, it really is kind of annoying. It kind of makes you, almost makes me want to fight my last two fights out and play the field, you know what I’m saying? It’s like, do I go where I’m celebrated or where I’m tolerated? Like, this shit’s a joke.”

“Regardless, I still have two fights left on my contract. So I have to fight it out regardless. I mean, dude, I’m like everyone else. I don’t want to leave the UFC. I want to be a fuckin’ UFC world champion. The problem is this fight gets me no closer to becoming a world champion, in my opinion. So of course I want to be a world champion, you know? I feel like this fight doesn’t really get me any closer. So I’m not happy about it. I’m fucking 31 years old, I’m not 21 anymore, how many of these fucking guys do I… If I get a top 10 opponent and I lose, that’s my fucking fault. I’ll go win a few more fights and come back. But right now I want another chance. There’s several of these guys who’ve gotten multiple chances.”

As for those “guys who’ve gotten multiple chances” Vick had a few choice words for Kevin Lee, Justin Gaethje, and Eddie Alvarez.

“I would whoop his ass,” Vick said of a potential fight with Lee. “He obviously can get me down a couple of times, but my ground game ain’t shit. I ain’t gonna lay on my back and just take a beating like Barboza did, I’m gonna get the fuck up.”

Speaking on Gaethje, Vick made his complaints with rankings clear. “It’s sad that the dude’s 1-2 in the UFC and he’s still gonna be ranked above me when I’m 9-1 in the UFC. And a lot of people want to say, ‘Well, he’s lost to top guys.’ Well he came in, the only guy you beat was on a three-fight losing streak when you came in. And now the guy is not even in the top 10 in featherweight. The one guy you beat was on a three-fight losing streak and the other two guys you lost to, dude.”

And in the case of Eddie Alvarez, Vick just doesn’t sound like he thinks the ‘Underground King’ would take the fight. “Put me on the same card as him, and if his opponent gets hurt I’ll gladly step in. Or I’d just gladly fight him to begin with, but I know that’s never gonna happen anytime soon.”

In the meantime, Vick sounds like he’s currently in “contract negotiations” with the UFC over his potential next bout, after making it clear that he “wasn’t happy about” getting an opponent ranked lower than him, and having a lower contract than other fighters being offered the same fight. So until those hurdles are cleared, it may be some time before fans see the ‘Texecutioner’ back in the Octagon.

Israel Adesanya nabs main event spot against Brad Tavares in third UFC bout

The UFC appears to be fully on board the Israel Adesanya hype train. The flashy world class kickboxer made his debut in the UFC just under three months ago, but after going 2-0 to start his UFC career, he’s nabbed a top-ranked opponent and a headlining spot on an upcoming fight card.

Adesanya is set to face #10 ranked middleweight Brad Tavares as the main event for the Ultimate Fighter 27 Finale on July 6th. The UFC announced the booking via Twitter.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

The ‘Last Stylebender’ is coming off a split decision win over Marvin Vettori at UFC on Fox: Poirier vs. Gaethje vack in April. Before that, he debut with a one-sided TKO drubbing of Rob Wilkinson at UFC 221.

For Tavares, this will mark his 17th bout in the UFC, having debuted against Seth Baczynski way back in 2010, following his stint on the Ultimate Fighter Season 11. He’s currently riding a four-fight win streak, having picked up his first stoppage since 2011, with a 3rd round KO of Krzysztof Jotko at the same UFC on FOX card where Adesanya beat Vettori. Overall, that latest win brings Tavares’ UFC record to 12-4 and 17-4 overall.

A win for Adesanya here would be an incredibly impressive accomplishment, given the caliber of his MMA opponents so far.

This Week in Knockouts: Fedor, Karate, and Isaac Dogboe

Whenever the UFC takes a break from their seemingly non-stop, year-round calendar of events, it’s always a good opportunity to take a step back and get a little broader look at the combat sports world. What’s going on outside the Octagon? More importantly, who got absolutely flattened in some random eastern European MMA event none of us have ever heard of before?

This week, the obvious spotlight belongs to Fedor Emelianenko, who picked up a first round TKO of Frank Mir to advance past the opening round of the Bellator heavyweight grand prix. Likewise, Ghanaian super bantamweight Isaac Dogboe took home a WBO world title, with a win over Jessie Magdaleno. And of course there’s lots of kickboxing, Muay Thai, and enough MMA to make your head spin.

As always, the real credit belongs to combat sports highlight Twitter and the fearless beings that watch any and all the fights they can get their hands on, in order to bring those signature moments to you. This week leans heavily on familiar names with Jolassanda and Caposa delivering. So be sure to give them a follow, and you’ll never miss a moment.

Bellator 198: Fedor vs. Mir

There was actually only one KO at Bellator’s latest ‘tent pole’ event, but it was a doozy. Especially for those fans that we’re thoroughly disheartened by the ‘Last Emperor’’s recent loss to Matt Mitrione. But, what the card lacked for knockouts it made up for in submissions, with every other bout on the main card ending via tap-out.

Heavyweight Fedor Emelianenko (37-5) ensured he’ll have another bout in the Bellator Grand Prix, with a short uppercut to the chin of Frank Mir (18-12) and some classic followup ground-and-pound.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Shooto Brasil 82

Flyweight Pedro Nobre reversed a 2-fight losing skid to move to 18-4-2 with a pair of killer overhand rights to the temple of Mario Junior Orelha, who dropped to 9-8.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Bantamweight Hudson Sombra (11-7) channeled his inner Katusnori Kikuno for a devastating body kick KO against Dwis Junior (4-8).

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Celtic Gladiator 20

Featherweight Maciej Szczepaniak moved to an unbeaten 4-0 in his MMA career with a pin-point liver kick KO to drop Patryk Dunski to 5-5.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Welterweight Piotr Poniedzialek (5-1) hit a gorgeous left high kick against Tomasz Terlikowski (7-5) to separate the man from his senses.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Berkut Young Eagles 4

Heavyweight Rizvan Liev made a spectacular pro debut, showing off some lightning fast 1-2s for a big man to drop Alexey Bondarchuk to 0-3.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Light heavyweight Anzor Shakhmurzaev (6-1) throwing fastballs to KO Igor Litoshik (11-8) early in the first round.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Other MMA

Flyweight Elton Alves tore through fellow debuting fighter Wallace Fonseca at Jungle fight 93, with hard knees and punches to the body, and eventually a clipping uppercut to seal the deal.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Lightweight Billy Oosthuizen made his own spectacular debut as the opener for EFC 69 in South Africa, dropping Pieter De Klerk to 0-6 with a big overhand right.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Flyweight Chikara Shimabukuro (14-12) caught Yasutaka Ishigami (7-6) with a hard left hand stepping in and followed it up with a hook to get the win at Deep 83 Impact.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Boxing

Super bantamweight Isaac Dogboe took his record to a perfect 19-0 with an 11th round TKO of previously unbeaten Jessie Magdaleno, who fell to 25-1 on the loss. Dogboe claimed Magdelano’s WBO championship belt in the process.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Featherweight Claudio Marrero (23-2) bounced back from his 2017 loss to Jesus Rojas with a clubbing right hand that put Jorge Lara (29-1-2) on the canvas early in round 1.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Kickboxing & Muay Thai

El Ameri Ali absolutely poured the offense on Javokhir Elboev on his way to a 4th round TKO in Tatneft, working the legs, body, and head.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Roman Mailov walked Bekhzhan Matysaev into the corner to land a flush right head kick at Tatneft for the stoppage win.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Carlos Prates with a crunching body knee KO at Phoenix Muay Thai.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Fabian Hundt seemed to be getting the worst of his Phoenix Muay Thai bout for a moment, before landing a stepping right elbow to get the KO.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Yodwicha Ken Muay Thai Gym put the finishing touches on Horrobin with a gorgeous stepping elbow at Top King Muay Thai.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Sangmanee Oomkatong Changmai Gym with the rare leg kick TKO at Top King Muay Thai.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Christian Hyatt lit up Daraeak Sutai MuayThai at MX Muay Xtreme.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Thiago Augusto went body head to finish his fight at MX Muay Xtreme.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Kittisak Chor Rattanachai with a step in right hand KO at the Battle Max Muay Thai.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Tinpetch Sit Sangchan with a slicing right elbow to drop his opponent at the Battle Max Muay Thai.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Petchtae Sor Jor Toypadrew with the kind of front elbow KO that only seems to happen in the art of eight limbs, at the Battle Max Muay Thai.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Karate Combat

The newest promotion in the combat sports sphere had a couple notable highlights.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

That’s everything from this week in knockouts. We’ll be back next week to once again highlight all that is glorious, violent, and consciousness separating in the world of fight sports. See you then!

New Jersey Athletic Commission denies Dvalishvili appeal, cites Goddard and McCarthy

It doesn’t come as much of a surprise, but Merab Dvalishvili won’t be getting his TKO loss to Ricky Simon scrubbed off the books. The Team Serra-Longo bantamweight looked to have a decision win clearly in hand at the UFC’s recent Fight Night event in Atlantic City, NJ, when referee Liam Kerrigan waved the bout off, after the final bell had sounded, declaring Simon the winner via TKO.

A last minute takedown at the end of the third round resulted in Dvalishvili spending the remainder of the fight stuck in a deep choke – his legs kicking and his face turning a vivid shade of purple. When the horn sounded and Simon released his grip, Dvalishvili’s body continued to twitch for a second or two, before flopping back to the mat, where he almost immediately attempted to sit up. In the eyes of the referee, and noted MMA official Marc Goddard (seated cageside) that was enough to declare that Dvalishvili had gone unconscious and had thus lost the bout.

On Wednesday, April 25, Dvalishvili’s manager Matthew Culley, of Battlescar Athlete Management LLC, filed a request to have the decision reviewed. Just two days later, Commissioner Larry Hazzard replied with a lengthy statement. The long and short of it was that Kerrigan’s decision would stand.

“The established written protocol for me to overturn a referee’s call; is, if in my discretion; the referee committed a self-evident and palpable error,” Hazzard wrote, before going on to describe the sequence of events that followed the end of the bout and led to the decision.

“We fully are aware of the disparity of the viewpoints of the declared outcome,” he continued. “This is true even after days of discussion by fans and media and countless video reviews. I can only state that Kerrigan was unwavering in his call, and that I believe him to be correct, or at least well within his discretion to make such a call. Despite the variety of opinions, we note that veteran referee Marc Goddard was cageside and agreed with the call. Furthermore, the most experienced referee in the sport’s history, John McCarthy (who watched offsite via television) felt that the outcome was just and proper.”

“In summary,” Hazzard wrote, after detailing the events following the in-cage announcement, “I do not find that Mr. Kerrigan committed a self-evident and palpable error; or even any error which comes close to that standard. Solely because a decision is disputed does not make such facially incorrect.”

Hazzard also noted that the commission does not require “multiple seconds of unconsciousness” in order to determine that a fighter has been rendered unable to continue. And, more particularly, he noted that the result should have been announced as a “TKO via technical submission,” however Hazzard believes that “Mr. Buffer, due to broadcast pressure, announced the decision simply as a TKO; and such was because he did not wait for the agency scorekeeper to conclude writing the announcer’s decision card.”

At least officially, that should lay the argument to rest. Merab Dvalishvili was defeated by Ricky Simon, on April 21st, in Atlantic City, via technical submission, at 5:00 of round 3. The unusual circumstances are likely to keep the fight as a point of debate and comparison to other, similar events in the future when they arise. But, as far as the record is concerned, Dvalishvili is going to end up stuck with the loss.

New, gruesome details emerge in Alexis Vila murder case

By the time Alexis Vila debuted in Bellator with a stunning KO win over Joe Warren, he had already allegedly had a hand in the murder and kidnapping of Camilo Salazar. Salazar was believed to be having an affair with the wife of a man named Manuel Marin, a close friend and father figure to the fighter.

Salazar’s burning remains were discovered by the side of the road on June 1st, 2011 – a little less than 3 months before Bellator 51. By way of an affidavit on the investigation, provided by the Miami-Dade County State Attorney’s Office, MMA Fighting supplied the horrifying details:

“Salazar’s body was found burning on the side of a road in Miami-Dade County the night of June 1, per the affidavit. His hands were bound and his body was partially burnt. An autopsy concluded that Salazar sustained multiple blunt force injuries to the head, a slit throat and burns to his pelvic area.”

The actual abduction and killing of Salazar was reportedly carried out by two men, Ariel Gandulla and Roberto Isaac. Isaac, said to be a member of the Latin Kings, who Vila met shortly after leaving prison in 2007, was arrested several days before Vila was taken into custody.

Per the affidavit, both Gandulla and Isaac said that they did not know Martin – on whose behalf they supposedly killed Salazar – and police believe that their friendships with Vila was the connection between the three men. The now 41-year-old Gandulla compiled a 8-9 (1 NC) pro MMA career while working and training alongside Vila – with a pair of bouts in the WEC marking the high point of his time as a competitive fighter. It is unknown at this time if he has been arrested.

Manuel Marin, the alleged mastermind of the murder, has fled the country

Manuel Martin apparently fled the country soon after Salazar’s body was discovered and has not returned since. Vila is being held with a pending immigration hold at the Turner Guilford Knight Correctional Center in Miami, both he and Gandulla are set to be charged with second-degree murder and kidnapping, along with conspiracy to commit both crimes. Vila is set to appear in court on May 10th for his arraignment.

For more information, check out MMA Fighting’s report.

The MMA Depressed-Us: Taktarov vs. Ruas

Another week without the UFC means another week with the MMA Depressed-Us. As always, we’re punishing ourselves for the all the months we’ve spent watching actual good fights, by watching some really bad ones. This week, we’re taking on a good/bad fight in Leonard Garcia vs. Jameel Massouh, a bad/bad fight in Francimar Barroso vs. Hans Stringer, and a disappointing fight between Oleg Taktarov and Marco Ruas (their first one). It’s a smorgasbord of meandering MMA action.

If you enjoyed the show, give us a ‘Like’ over on YouTube, and catch the audio on SoundCloud or iTunes. And while you’re there, subscribe to MMANATIONDOTCOM. That way you’ll always be among the first to get the latest BE shows, interviews, and analysis.

WARNING: THE SHOW APPEARS TO ONLY BE LOADING PROPERLY ON PHONE/TABLET, BUT NOT ON DESKTOP (and may not be loading at all in some areas).*

*it now appears to be working fine, but I’m keeping the warning up just in case.

The MMA Vivisection – Bellator 198: Fedor vs. Mir picks, odds, & analysis

Bellator takes over the prime Saturday night slot this weekend with an event in Rosemont, Illinois. And to their credit, with the UFC not on the schedule this weekend, they’re taking advantage of the spotlight with a marquee fight… even if it’s a few years later than most would want it to be. Fedor Emelianenko is taking on former UFC heavyweight champion Frank Mir, in Mir’s first bout since his USADA suspension back in 2016. Accompanying the notable names are a bevy of fighters Bellator is looking to shine a spotlight on, including Neiman Gracie & Dillon Danis.

As always, if you enjoyed the show, give us a ‘Like’ over on YouTube. And while you’re there, subscribe to MMANATIONDOTCOM. That way you’ll always be among the first to get the latest BE shows, interviews, and analysis.

Here’s a look at the Bellator 198 fight card as it stands now:

PARAMOUNT NETWORK MAIN CARD
Fedor Emelianenko vs. Frank Mir
Emmanuel Sanchez vs. Sam Sicilia
Neiman Gracie vs. Javier Torres
Dillon Danis vs. Kyle Walker
Rafael Lovato Jr. vs. Gerald Harris

ONLINE PRELIMS
Rmandel Cameron vs. PJ Cajigas
Dan Stittgen vs. Mark Stoddard
Eric Wisely vs. Morgan Sickinger
Matt Paul vs. Brian Booth
Joey Diehl vs. Nate Williams
Tom Shoaff vs. Mike Budnik
James Bennett vs. Dustin Stusse
Asef Askar vs. Andrew Johnson
Corey Jackson vs. Adil Benjilany
Tom Angeloff vs. Sultan Umar
Adam Maciejewski vs. Rob Morrow

John McCarthy says Dvalishvili stoppage was ‘right outcome’ but TKO call makes no sense

Add another voice to those that think referee Liam Kerrigan made the right call, Saturday night in Atlantic City, when he awarded Ricky Simon the victory over Merab Dvalishvili. The two bantamweights were engaged in a back and fourth war for 14 minutes at UFC Fight Night: Barboza vs. Lee (largely won by Team Serra-Longo’s Dvalishvili), when Simon defended a late takedown with a guillotine. And although Dvalishvili made it to the final bell, Simon was awarded a TKO victory.

Referee Marc Goddard – who was working with the commission that night – backed up Kerrigan’s decision to award Simon the win, saying, “He was actually out. And in that instance, it’s like any other instance if you pick up a rear-naked choke or guillotine.” Now longtime UFC referee, and current voice-in-the-booth for Bellator MMA, ‘Big’ John McCarthy is making it known that he agrees… at least with Simon winning. Maybe not so much with the TKO part.

McCarthy took to Twitter over the weekend to give his thoughts and respond to various questions about the decision.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

He also gave his thoughts on a couple of similar situations; reflecting on Anderson Silva’s fight with Michael Bisping, where Silva appeared to knock Bisping out at the end of the third round, but the fight continued regardless. And there’s his take from January of last year, when Celine Haga lost a unanimous decision to Amy Montenegro, despite rendering Montenegro unconscious via rear naked choke as the final bell was sounding. Haga appealed the loss, but to no success.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

It may be in those other two examples that the real problem with Kerrigan’s decision to award Dvalishvili the win lies. Not that he made the wrong move, but in past, similar situations the fight has continued on to the judges scorecards, even when it shouldn’t have.

Dvalishvili likely won’t have any better case to challenge the decision than Haga, either, despite being on the opposite end of the referee’s ruling. Commissions tend to defer to the judgement of their referees in these scenarios. So while eventually, the right man may very well have won last weekend, MMA officiating and rule enforcement is none the clearer for it.

Leslie Smith offers additional details on UFC release: ‘It turned into a really big moral issue for me’

When Leslie Smith arrived in Atlantic City, NJ this week, it was likely with every intention of fighting. She had been training for weeks to face bantamweight prospect Aspen Ladd on the undercard of UFC Fight Night: Barboza vs. Lee. But, what now seems just as clear is that, win or lose, the UFC may not have had any intention giving her another bout in the Octagon.

Smith has been at the head of the burgeoning ‘Project Spearhead’ movement. An organization she launched with the hope of organizing UFC fighters to challenge their independent contractor status. And it hasn’t been something she’s done behind closed doors; speaking openly about the organizations intent, and making public appeals to fellow fighters to sign membership cards.

That kind of labor organizing may have had a lot to do with why Smith ended last week, not in the cage, as planned, but instead with $62,000 and the last fight on her UFC contract cancelled.

The trouble started when Smith’s opponent, Aspen Ladd, missed weight by 1.8 lbs. Not a huge amount, but enough to be a bargaining opportunity for Smith. She’d take the bout with Ladd, at a catchweight, if the UFC would extend her contract – which was on it’s final fight. Seemingly a good deal to keep an action fighter on a two win streak. Especially one known for her fan-friendly style and willingness to take on all comers. But, not a deal the UFC was interested in.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

At least publicly, it’s a highly unusual move for the organization, which has often used last-minute fight cancellations as a reason to extend the contracts of their talent automatically. And who have built a reputation for stinginess when paying fighters for bouts their opponents withdrew from with too little time to find a replacement. Japanese flyweight Ulka Sasaki only got $10,000 of of his $21,000 show money – to say nothing of his win bonus – when Magomed Bibulatov was pulled from this same Atlantic City card on weigh-in day. It seems reasonable to say that the UFC was unusually ready to pay Smith just to go away.

“They said they had no interest in extending my contract at this time, and instead, they offered me my show and win money,” Smith said in an interview with MMA Junkie shortly after the news broke. “So they said they’ll just pay me off, and since they’re giving me the win bonus, it counts as the last fight on my contract. So, I guess that would mean I’m a free agent now.”

The way Smith has framed it – especially given her position with Project Spearhead – if she was going to be paid in full anyway, she just couldn’t justify “fighting for free.”

“That was really hard, because my whole thing, what some people would say I’ve probably sacrificed my UFC career for, is Project Spearhead. And one of the major tenets of that is that fighters should not be fighting for free,” Smith said. “They should get paid what they’re worth. And since I had the chance to get the money and not fight, then I would have been fighting for free. It turned into a really big moral issue for me as opposed to wanting to take the fight.”

Hopefully for Smith she finds a new promotional home before too long, but opportunities for women to make the same kind of money and fight on the same kind of stage may be few and far between outside the UFC.

Referee Marc Goddard on Dvalishvili TKO loss: ‘The right guy went away with the win’

The problem isn’t so much that MMA doesn’t have rules, it’s that so many of them seem to be so rarely applied. Much of what happens in the flow of a fight gets limited to a verbal warning as action continues. Occasionally the action will break for a low blow or an eye poke, but just about everything else tends to be more of a ‘guideline’ than a hard and fast regulation.

More broadly, that means that referees have a lot of discretion when it comes to how rules are applied. Did that cage grab warrant a verbal warning? A reset in the center of the cage? A point deduction? At UFC Fight Night: Barboza vs. Lee referee Liam Kerrigan was faced with a much more difficult call, with larger implications.

UFC newcomer Ricky Simon defeated Merab Dvalishvili, officially, at 5:00 of round 3 in their bantamweight contest in Atlantic City. A fight Dvalishvili had largely controlled ended with the final bell and Simon on top, a deep guillotine choke sunk in, Dvalishvili’s face purple and his legs kicking for almost a minute straight.

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

When the bell rung and the referee instructed Simon to release the choke, Dvalishvili remained on the mat. And whether he did so due to a lack of consciousness, relief and exhaustion at having survived, or official instruction not to move, it seems that moment cost him everything. The referee ruled that, during the course of the final minute he had been rendered unable to continue, and thus Simon was the winner via TKO.

While he wasn’t in the cage for that particular match, veteran official Marc Goddard was working with the commission on the night and he agrees entirely with the decision that was made. Speaking to MMA Fighting, Goddard gave his view on the stoppage, and why Simon deserved the win.

“I think it was pretty clear at the end of the fight, maybe even before, when the bell sounded, Dvalishvili … he was out,” Goddard said. “He was actually out. And in that instance, it’s like any other instance if you pick up a rear-naked choke or a guillotine. The fact that he drifts into unconsciousness was actually — it should be recorded as a submission, technical submission.”

“There was a bit of confusion, it was loud, and I just wanted to make sure that they weren’t going to go to the scorecards, because that’s the way it looked like it was going to be heading,” Goddard explained. “But the referee Liam Kerrigan, to his credit, when he saw [Dvalishvili] was out, he actually waved it off. And I think there was a little bit of a rush, people thought we were going to try and read the scorecards, so I said, ‘No, no, no. The guy has lost the fight.’ Even though he came around pretty sharp afterwards, he most definitely lost the fight under the ruling and the right guy went away with the win.”

It’s exactly the kind of tough call that commissions are typically willing to leave to the referee’s discretion. When Simon released the submission, if the referee thought that Dvalishvili may have actually been unconscious at the time, he had the power to make that call. And while the commission could potentially overturn it (and it should be expected that Dvalishvili will challenge the ruling) AC’s are notoriously loathe to act against the decision making of their referees.

The question now isn’t so much, will Dvalishvili get a win back, but instead, will the next referee faced with a similar situation make the same call?