UFC 299 debacle with Dustin Poirier shows nothing ever changes

If it were anything other than combat sports, this would have been felt like something of a minor scandal brewing for the UFC. For MMA fans, though, it’s pretty much all old hat. Ari Emanuel may have put a corporate shine on Dana White’s fight company, but in some of the least appealing ways, it’s still the business we’ve known for decades.

Just how many unsigned bouts has the UFC been promoting?

This last week we saw an announced headlining fight between Vicente Luque and Sean Brady fall apart after it was revealed that—despite the UFC’s assurance that the bout was set—the fighters had not, in fact come to an agreement on the booking. More particularly that Sean Brady had hoped to be able to take the fight, but was recovering from an injury that ultimately prevented him from being ready in time.

More notable than that bout, however, was a whole storm of nonsense kicked up by Dustin Poirier. Currently set for the co-main event of UFC 299, the ‘Diamond’ took to social media in the past couple days to announce that he had failed to reach an agreement with the UFC for his bout with Benoit Saint Denis. With seats already on sale and a couple of weeks of UFC advertising in place, Dana White & co. had apparently been selling wolf tickets…

Ultimately, Poirier course corrected, telling fans that he hadn’t spoken to his manager in the past few days and did not realize that a deal had actually been reached in the meantime. The fact remains, though, that between Poirier’s reveal that a contract had seemingly just been signed and a statement from Saint Denis’ coach that neither he nor his fighter knew who their opponent was before the bout had been announced, that the whole thing held onto the stink of standard UFC negotiating tactics.

It’s not hard to understand where these tactics come from. When the Fertittas first purchased what would become the world’s largest MMA promotion it was firmly in the ‘dark ages’ trying to find a foothold with a government that had seen their early events and decided that it was too violent for sanctioning. In that tenuous financial environment, and with Joe Silva as the pitboss in talent negotations, the UFC made absolutely sure that no matter what fighter they were working with or what fight they were trying to make, they had to come out on top. To put a finer point on it, the UFC built its reputation on being ruthless.

The UFC may be huge but they still negotiate like a hungry start-up

Fifteen years of that steely resolve later, and the business went up for sale with a price tag over $4 billion. They had concentrated their power over fighters in every single way possible. They took away sponsors, they took away clothing options, they secured image rights. Exclusive contracts became the norm, as did long-term multi-fight deals with matching clauses and negotiation windows. Meanwhile, the UFC also created pipelines for finding fresh fighters that ensured that cards could always be filled. Anyone who really did want to leave wouldn’t be missed for long.

Today, the UFC is a financial juggernaut, raking in money through corporate partnerships, licensing and broadcast fees that ensure whether they’re putting on events in front of a crowd of 20,000 or 20 they’re making millions. And while Silva may be gone, as long as Dana White is still here the cheapskate attitude that brought them up doesn’t look like it’s about to go away.

Read the rest at the Bloody Elbow Substack.


You know you can count on us for quick, consistent quality UFC and MMA coverage. Bloody Elbow is an independent, reader supported publication. Please subscribe to our newsletter to keep up with our best work and learn how you can support the site.

Join the new Bloody Elbow

Our Substack is where we feature the work of writers like Zach Arnold, John Nash and Karim Zidan. We’re fighting for the sport, the fighters and the fans. Please help us by subscribing today.

UFC 299 booking confusion catches Dustin Poirier

It’s been a classic negotiating tactic of the UFC for years now. Get fans hyped up by announcing a booking, only for it to later turn out that the fight everyone was excited for was never actually booked. It was a tactic that truly became obvious to fans during Gilbert Melendez’s time with the UFC, specifically a planned Khabib Nurmagomedov fight that was announced by Dana White & co. while Melendez was still negotiating for a new contract with the promotion.

Melendez instead opted to go to Bellator, but was pulled back to the world’s largest MMA promotion via a ‘matching clause’. He then went on to face Anthony Pettis as opposing coaches on the Ultimate Fighter before vying against ‘Showtime’ for the lightweight title. The Nurmagomedov bout never materialized.

Dustin Poirier turns down Benoit Saint Denis fight

More so than contract negotiation tactics, the current version of the UFC has seen a consistent problem with stagnation at the upper ends of their divisional rankings. A voting panel that seems inconsistent on demoting fighters for inactivity or for a lack of relevant wins, and a realization from fighters that there’s more risk than reward in taking on lower-ranked opposition, has created a series of contender pools populated by the same few familiar faces seemingly for years on end. Nowhere has this problem been more present than the lightweight division.

Perhaps that’s why Dana White took a stab at announcing a bout between former interim lightweight title holder—and #3 ranked—Dustin Poirier against fast rising #11 ranked talent Benoit Saint Denis. A surefire banger that also seemed like an all risk/no reward booking for the ‘Diamond’. If fans might have been wondering why Poirier might take on such a dangerous opponent who had so little to offer him in terms of name recognition or title fight relevance, it turns out he hadn’t.

“I reached out to [Dustin Poirier] about his tweet that the BSD fight at 299 is off,” MMA Fighting’s Ariel Helwani reported. “His response: ‘There was no contractual agreement before the fight was announced and we couldn’t come to terms.”

Even Benoit Saint Deni’s coach recently admitted that neither he nor his fighter had any clue about the fight booking right up until the day the announcement was made public.

Or then again, maybe this was all just one big misunderstanding.

Dustin Poirier backtracks, says UFC 299 fight is still on

Chalk one up for Dana White. The UFC boss may have pushed the news that Dustin Poirier was fighting Benoit Saint Denis as a pressure tactic to get him to take a less desirable booking than he might otherwise have been looking for, but it sounds like it actually worked.

Shortly after denying that he had accepted the fight at all, Poirier came back to Twitter to announce that his team had, in fact, come to terms with the UFC in the last few days. UFC 299 is still a go.

Never one to miss a chance to gloat—and despite the fighters themselves involved saying that they only came to an agreement after the bout was announced—Dana White quickly took to social media to bash MMA Fighting’s Guilherme Cruz for picking up Poirier’s statement and fleshing out the reporting.

It has to be noted that nothing in the screenshots White shared suggested that either a contract had been signed or even that Saint Denis knew the Poirier would be his opponent. All these screenshots from White show are that Saint Denis had verbally agreed to a potential fight at UFC 299. Seems like a strange reason to put someone on blast considering even Poirier didn’t know his fight had been 100% agreed upon just within the past couple days.

End of the day, it’s good news for fans. Saint-Denis vs. Poirier promises to be an absolute war. UFC 299 is set to be headlined by Sean O’Malley vs. Marlon Vera for the bantamweight title. Alongside the main and co-main events, the card is expected to feature the debut of former Bellator star Michael Page, taking on Kevin Holland as well as Gilbert Burns vs. Jack Della Maddalena and Petr Yan vs. Song Yadong.